After an injury, medical appointments, calls and paperwork can pile up.
In fact, approximately 54.5 million Americans received medical care for avoidable injuries in 2024, according to the National Safety Council. Of course, this does not equate to the number of personal injury claims, but provides an indication of the scale of injury in the US. Once an injury can be linked to another’s negligent or intentional act, there may be scope to bring a personal injury claim.
Being aware of the common trajectory of an injury claim can help you make considered choices, and keep a note of important steps along the way.
What You’ll Learn
- Do I Have a Personal Injury Claim?
- Receiving Medical Treatment & Building Your Evidence
- Pursuing an Insurance Claim and/or Negotiating a Settlement
- Taking the Claim to Court
- How long will my claim take?
- Possible outcomes from an Injury Claim
- Conclusion
Do I Have a Personal Injury Claim?
Not every accident will result in another party being liable to compensate you. As with most personal injury/tort cases, there will need to be proof of a duty, breach, causation, damages etc.
For example, a motorist fails to stop at a signal, causing a collision. While that may be helpful to demonstrate liability, you would still require proof of the incident, the injuries sustained, and consequent loss as a result.
These will initially form some of the main questions to ask:
- Was there a negligent party?
- Can their conduct be linked to the harm you suffered?
- Have you suffered any identifiable losses?
- Do you know of, or have, any insurance to recover these from?
It may be appropriate to consult a personal injury attorney where liability may be contested, there are long-term consequences, or the insurer has challenged the circumstances of your injury. You can speak to attorneys for injury claims about this, who can advise on your prospects and position you ahead of any lowball settlement or expiry of limitation periods.
A lawsuit isn’t always the first step. Begin by finding out whether there is a claim worth pursuing.
Receiving Medical Treatment & Building Your Evidence
You will want to seek and adhere to a course of medical treatment, to help alleviate your injuries and allow you to heal as soon as possible. Your medical provider will generate a series of medical records documenting your complaints, clinical findings, and treatment received, which you can retain.
You will then want to collate information that may be relevant to prove how the incident occurred, such as:
- Images of the accident, any damage, and/or your injuries;
- Contact details of any third parties, e.g. bystanders, eyewitnesses, etc.;
- Police/accident reference, if applicable;
- Any invoices, correspondence, referrals, prescriptions, etc.; and
- Earnings, if you have lost time from work, or incurred any loss of income as a result of the injury.
Ideally, retain hard copies/images wherever possible, as you may struggle to source some information retrospectively.
It can also be helpful to make a log of the impact of the injury on your everyday activities, e.g. difficulty driving, performing manual labour, etc. This may not be reflected in medical invoices, but will help illustrate the knock-on consequences of your injury.
Try not to overstate your condition or speculate as to what the root cause may be, and stick to providing factual information.
Pursuing an Insurance Claim and/or Negotiating a Settlement
Whether or not litigation follows, you or your agent will typically make a claim against the responsible party’s insurer, identifying the insurance policy(ies) that you believe may be implicated, and outline the injury sustained.
The insurer will consider your claim, and may make queries about, for example, the apportionment of fault, applicability of the policy, and request further details regarding your injuries and medical treatment, etc. You may also be notified that your claim has been disputed, in whole or part, by the insurer, following an initial assessment by an adjuster.
Once sufficient information has been gathered, including as to any anticipated, ongoing or long-term treatment, you (or your agent) may submit a letter of claim/demand, setting out the key facts of the incident, the injury, and your total sum claimed, inclusive of various heads of loss, if applicable. The scope of these will vary depending on the jurisdiction, your particular circumstances, and applicable law.
The insurer may then seek to negotiate, or turn down, the amount proposed, and/or put forward a lower sum, from which you will want to assess its merits.
It is important to familiarise yourself with any release/settlement, which you will normally be asked to sign, to signify your agreement to forego your rights to bring any further claim, before agreeing to accept the final sum. Before signing, consider expected future treatment, outstanding bills and the rights the settlement would release.
While it can be tempting to settle for a lump-sum payment, there is often no recourse, once a matter has concluded.
Taking the Claim to Court
Should you fail to reach an amicable resolution, or are unable to agree on, for example, liability, extent of injury, compensation, etc., you may choose to issue court proceedings, subject to the limitation period remaining open.
In California, a civil lawsuit generally starts when a complaint is filed with the court. The defendant is then served with a summons and complaint and may respond to the allegations.
Thereafter, there will usually be a period of disclosure, whereby each party will exchange and serve relevant information, documents, interrogatories, and/or attend for examination/depositions, as appropriate, to obtain information to assist their respective claims/defence.
This process may yield further evidence, which you can consider, albeit it may take time to obtain, particularly if it resides with third parties, is not readily available, or multiple parties are involved, etc.
The parties may continue to engage in settlement discussions, potentially via a mediator, post-litigation, with a view to resolving the matter, and avoiding a full-blown trial. If unsuccessful, the parties’ dispute will be determined by a trier of fact, i.e. Judge/Jury, as relevant, having regard to applicable law, procedure, and evidence, etc.
Of course, commencing litigation is not synonymous with going to trial, but merely initiates a further procedural process to resolve your claim, which may conclude, if settled, pre-hearing.
How long will my claim take?
There is no set timescale, which will largely depend on, among other things, the extent/ nature of the injury, length of treatment, availability of evidence, whether fault is disputed, whether proceedings have to be brought, etc.
That said, you should differentiate between how long it will take to resolve a claim, versus the limitation period, which will dictate when you have to file your claim, if applicable. For instance, the general rule in California, is to bring a personal injury action within two years of the date of injury, save where otherwise provided. For many injury claims against a California government agency, you generally must submit an administrative claim within six months of the injury. If the agency mails a written rejection, you generally have six months from the mailing date to file a lawsuit. Different rules may apply if the agency does not respond. The rules will differ elsewhere, and depending on the type of matter.
Accordingly, do not assume you can continue to pursue insurance negotiations indefinitely, and take into account any applicable time limits, to avoid forfeiting your claim. Speak to a qualified attorney, if required, particularly if your injury is significant, and/or the limitation date is imminent/unclear, to avoid running out of time once you have completed your course of treatment.
Possible outcomes from an Injury Claim
Not all injury claims will culminate in a windfall, and may result in, among others, a settlement, court award, or, if unsuccessful, nil recovery, including, for example, where you are unable to prove that another was at fault, or you did not sustain any compensatable damages, etc. Moreover, obtaining a favourable award/judgment does not guarantee that you will recover your award, which may necessitate further enforcement, etc.
Assuming, however, you succeed, you may be entitled to compensation, if supported by the evidence, for, e.g. medical, lost earnings, future loss of earning capacity, pain & suffering, etc., in accordance with the law, quantum, and any relevant principles, e.g. mitigation, contributory negligence, etc.
Shared-fault rules differ by state. Comparative negligence may reduce compensation based on the injured person’s share of fault, while contributory negligence can bar recovery if the claimant was partly responsible. You should therefore be aware of the law, and assess whether this will affect your recovery, if applicable.
Finally, bear in mind the net sum, which you stand to receive, once, e.g. costs, disbursements, third-party, etc. have been deducted, from your gross sum recovered, if any, and, if using a personal injury firm, be sure to understand the terms of the retainer, how, and if, expenses, etc. are recouped, and, if possible, seek a schedule of these, before entering into any agreement.
Ultimately, you want to achieve the best, and most informed, outcome, weighing up the pros and cons of concluding your claim, and accepting, say, a discounted settlement, vs proceeding to a hearing, if appropriate, to maximise your chances of a successful outcome, etc.
Conclusion
There are, therefore, various stages to consider, and actions to take, in the lead up to, and post, an accident, that can help inform and improve your chances of a successful claim, if applicable, and, importantly, not overlook the relevant time limit(s).
Ensure you understand and evaluate all relevant factors, before making any irreversible decisions, that you may come to regret, later.